Pearson pulse transformers feature a minimum of solid insulation in regions of high electric field. One of these construction prevents damage to the transformer by accidental flashovers due either to poor oil or to overvoltages beyond the everyday 50 to 100% safety factor built into the transformer. The intentional weakest region is between the high voltage corona ring and the core. These are metal surfaces and flashovers between them have negligible effect on the surfaces for the energies involved in even the best power line-type pulsers.
Despite the voltage stand-off safety factor built into the transformer, and the feature of with the ability to withstand reasonable flashovers without damage, there are still occasional cases of damaged transformers. On inspection these units invariably show that they’ve been operated in oil that was dirty or there have been enormous over-voltages, sometimes approaching a million volts for a unit rated at a small fraction of this value. It is hoped that the following notes will help the user avoid these difficulties.
The necessity for good oil is mostly accepted, but often the particular precautions necessary are usually not understood. Pulse modulator malfunction shouldn’t be so generally appreciated as an important and frequent cause of accidental overvoltages. In fact, it is often a significant source of trouble. Over-voltages might be difficult to detect and the causes difficult to diagnose.
Ordinary transformer insulating oil supplied by the major oil and electrical companies is basically satisfactory for prime voltage pulse use. The problems that arise are most frequently because of contamination by dirt, air and water. The condition of the oil as initially installed have to be good. Once installed satisfactorily, one must assure that it stays good.
Reasonable effort must be made to make sure the transformer itself, the tank, and the opposite parts within the oil are free from dust, lint, chips, etc. before filling. It’s difficult to get all the parts absolutely clean. The slightest amount of dirt within the oil could be a potential source of flashover when it drifts through a region of high electric field. Filtering the oil is generally indicated at this point.
The oil filter element should be of a type that filters very small particles. “Fuller’s Earth” filters, or equivalent, able to filtering fine particles are necessary. If a filter unit is part of the transformer tank assembly, running the filter unit for a period of a few hours before operation will clean up most of the dirt particles. If there isn’t a continuous filtering unit, placing the inlet and outlet hoses of the pump and filter in diagonally opposite corners of the tank will give most rapid filtering of the oil volume.
Once the oil is clean, several precautions ought to be taken:
1. Put a lid on the tank and keep it there. Remove only for brief periods of time for initial inspection if necessary. Once operation of the unit is going smoothly, the cover and gasket ought to be bolted in place.
2. Do not put hands in oil without filtering the oil afterwards. Even clean hands and arms seem to deteriorate the oil.
3. If an accidental over-voltage leads to a flashover, the oil could have a small amount of carbon in it, weakening the oil. Filtering is a wise thing to do if any spark-overs occur.
4. If the oil should inadvertently become so carbonized that it becomes perceptibly darkened, then the oil is weakened to the point where corona tracks might be established on the solid insulation on which the transformer windings are wound. Once corona tracks are established, which might happen at less than rated voltage once oil is badly weakened, the tracks will grow until complete breakdown occurs.
Occasional Sparkover in First Few Hours of Operation Sometimes it’s found that, although performance of the modulator is ideal and the oil very clean, a sparkover may occur after several hours of running time. This can be explained by the presence of a lone piece of dirt, perhaps a nearly invisible piece of lint, which is drifting slowly about within the transformer tank. It might probably take hours of drifting before it enters a region of high electric field. The sparkover demolishes the particle, and the resultant flashover contaminants may become so disbursed as to cause
no further trouble.
In a stably operating system, with no over-voltages, thoroughly clean oil, sealed tank, and no undetected corona from some sharp high voltages points within the tank, there should be no need for continuous filtering. But if all these conditions should not certain to prevail always, the expense of downtime and its attendant mess may be largely avoided by continuous filtering.
A typical 60 Hz oil tester can be used to check pulse transformer oil. The breakdown point of the oil ought to be at the least 30 kV rms for a standard oil cup with electrode spacing of 0.1 inch.
The oil test cup (and likewise any other vessel used for dipping up the oil) must be rinsed in clean oil, aside from the oil to be tested, in order to avoid possible contamination of the oil to be tested. Oil should be taken from the transformer tank as utilized in operation. Repeated tests needs to be made. The bottom reading is the numerous one since the density of contaminants could be low.
Air contamination shouldn’t be as frequent a source of trouble as dirt, but could cause problems. A certain quantity of air is always absorbed in the oil and causes no problem. Free bubbles within the oil which can be in the high electric fields will make sure to cause breakdown. A number of the ways during which bubbles get in the oil are as follows:
1. On pumping oil right into a transformer tank the oil, on striking the open oil surface, or a tough surface, captures air bubbles. This lowers the breakdown value of the oil markedly. A few of these bubbles float back to the surface and burst. Others are absorbed into the oil. Allowing the oil to stand for a day will bring it back to full test. A useful technique is to let the oil flow almost parallel to the surface of a tank wall in order that the stream spreads out without capturing bubbles. Then when the depth of oil is sufficient the hose is lowered beneath the surface of the oil.
2. At the start of oil pumping there is usually a certain amount of air trapped in the pumping system. This gets churned up into bubbles when pumping starts. If a spare drum of oil is accessible, this startup process can be done in it and the hoses then transferred to the transformer tank.
3. If a circulating pump is an integral a part of the tank assembly, this churning sometimes can’t be avoided. A compensating feature is that the pump will suck up bubbles together with the oil and take them out of the tank.
4. A leak within the negative pressure side of the pumping system will pull in air. That is broken into bubbles which end up in the transformer tank.
5. The core warms up during high average power transformer operation. It could actually then release air trapped in the laminations. These air bubbles can drift up through the transformer and enter the regions of high electric fields. Pearson transformer cores are impregnated with oil under vacuum to remove this air.
As with air, oil contains a small amount of water which under normal laboratory room temperature and humidity, and over a protracted period of time, reaches an equilibrium that does not normally harm the oil. However, if the oil is in storage or in use in areas where the temperature and humidity aren’t held within bounds, water will condense and collect on the underside of the container. Oil-breakdown value suffers under this condition.
Water is widely used for cooling. All too often mishaps occur and water is spilled in the oil or small undetected water leaks drip water into the oil. Where that is a factor it is best to specify a divided tank, so that the transformer compartment can be sealed against entry of moisture.
If water drops or puddles should exist on the bottom of a transformer tank or storage drum, and pumping should pickup some of this water, it will be broken up and emulsified with the oil. The water droplets can then follow the surface of the transformer. High voltage operation under this condition will end in breakdown of the solid insulating material of the transformer.
If water is standing in the bottom of a container, the oil must be pumped off until a remainder which includes the water will be thrown away. Then a heater immersed in the oil for a protracted period (days) will gradually drive off the moisture. Other methods (all requiring special equipment) for removing moisture are:
1. Water absorbing filter.
2. Distillation type oil refiner.
3. Centrifugal type oil refiner.
4. Spraying heated oil into an evacuated chamber.
It is feasible for the pulse modulator to malfunction in such a way as to end in over-voltaging the transformer, as well as other important components such because the PFN and the switch. Among the possible causes are:
1. A mix of too-low load resistance and an inadequate PFN reverse charge removal circuit.
2. A switch that fires spontaneously during interpulse periods.
3. Continuous conduction of the switch.
4. Load resistance too high.
5. A mix of two or more problems listed above.
Combination of Too Low Resistance and Inadequate Discharge Circuit for Removing Reverse Charge
This problem is covered (Vol. 5 p. 417 f.) of the M.I.T. Radiation Laboratory Series, Glasoe, etc., and is an issue that normally receives attention. One possible difficulty is that the reverse charge discharge circuit does not remove the reverse charge fast enough. It should do that even for complete load short circuit at full charging voltage. What can happen then is that the charging cycle can get well under way before the reverse charge is completely removed.
Successive pyramiding of the charging voltage can occur. A simple test that will help show whether this circuit is operating adequately is to momentarily short circuit the load. The peak charging voltage should not rise. If a full voltage test of this sort is ruled out, a low voltage test might be performed. This would show whether the discharge circuit is properly proportioned. It wouldn’t show whether the current capabilities of the discharge diode were adequate.
This problem is probably the most serious causes of component overvoltaging. It is also one that is difficult to avoid and difficult to cope with. With the tendency toward ever-higher peak and average pulse powers, the issue of securing a very adequate switch becomes increasingly difficult. This is coupled with the necessity for keeping costs within limits so that completely adequate instrumentation and protective circuits usually are not always included as a matter after all in the design of the pulse modulator.
If a pulse switch has any tendency toward spontaneous firing during the interpulse period and there is no positive type of protection included specifically for this malfunction, then the pulse transformer and other components will definitely be overvoltaged.
Consider the next explanation. If the switch closes while charging current is flowing, a normal or subnormal pulse voltage will appear on the load. Oftentimes the switch will then conduct continuously and the traditional over current breaker protection should operate, but there won’t necessarily (see below) be an overvoltage. If the switch should clear at the top of the pulse as it normally does, a new charging cycle is started. But this new charging cycle starts with finite current. For an initial charging current greater than zero, the subsequent charging voltage crest might be higher. Then if the switch is closed again at it is normal time a bigger voltage pulse appears at the load.
In fact, if the switch has a tendency to close spontaneously for normal charging voltage, then it will likely be still more apt to shut spontaneously at the upper than normal charging voltage. If this continues, enormous voltages could be generated.
If, however, the switch should close spontaneously some time after the charging cycle was completed, but before the following normal pulse, then a traditional pulse can be formed. A traditional charging cycle will then be started. But while this cycle is in progress, the conventional trigger occurs, the switch closes, and then the process for over-voltage goes into operation since now a charging cycle is started with finite charging current already flowing.
A simple device that can help prevent over-voltaging the transformer (but not necessarily other components) is a fast over-voltage sensing circuit that can automatically prevent the subsequent and all succeeding triggers from being applied to the switch if the charging voltage rises above a predetermined value. A voltage divider giving faithful waveform division is critical here. A bleeder resistance for draining off the PFN charge ought to be a part of the circuit too. It’s prudent also to show off
the power supply automatically at the same time (see section on continuous conduction).
Other protective measures are possible. One is a spark-gap and low resistance in series across the primary, with the gap set to fire for any amount of over-voltage. Another is thyrite across the first. Both of those are inherently imperfect but are better than nothing.
Obviously a switch with adequate voltage hold-off capability is known as for and each effort should be made during design to assure this. Series operation of switches is a possibility, but one that ought to usually be avoided. Considered one of the issues that has been encountered with series switches is that of making certain that the charging voltage is equalized between the series tubes. Which means that the capacitances in addition to resistances should be equal for the reason that charging voltage has ac components in addition to dc. The capacitances ought to be measured in an actual circuit to make certain that stray capacitances will not be upsetting the balance. Individual triggering of all series switches is recommended for positive closing of the individual series switches. This is relatively simple to do with an appropriate multisecondary trigger transformer or separate, paralleled-primary trigger transformers.
Another difficulty that may occur is that the switch may conduct continuously. An over-voltage is just not created initially. However, the charging inductance and the filter capacitor undergo a half cycle of oscillation. At the tip of the half cycle the current is stopped by the charging diodes. Now the voltage is reversed on the filter capacitor. Current now flows from the facility
supply to recharge the filter capacitor. But this can be a situation completely analogous to resonant charging a PFN having a reverse charge, except that the capacitive element is now the filter capacitor and the inductive element is the inductance. The result’s a tendency to charge the filter capacitor to more than double the traditional power supply value. After all, all of the succeeding pulse components are then correspondingly over-voltaged. Obviously, the facility supply circuit breakers and current sensing circuits ought to be fast-acting for the case of continuous conduction of the switch.
Proper instrumentation and calibration is expensive in time and money. Sometimes the temptation is to make assumptions regarding the load resistance. Voltage dividers and pulse-current transformers should be used on the load to make sure that the load resistance is correct at full operating voltage. Dummy loads whose resistances vary with temperature ought to be watched. A mismatch on the high side for the load can allow the transformer voltage to be too high even though the charging voltage is an appropriate value.
A standard failing on the a part of an engineer or technician trying to locate trouble in a malfunctioning pulse system, is the tendency to assume there is just one system malfunction. Actually, it’s more common that there are several problems co-existing in the equipment. In testing to see if a specific malfunction exists, as much of the circuit that can be eliminated or replaced by simpler components should be. An example could be that of first operating a pulse modulator right into a resistive load at full peak and average power. Then add the transformer operating right into a resistive load, again at full power. Then the diode type load can replace the resistive load. This process can partially avoid assigning of the trouble to the pulse transformer or the diode load or the reaction of those on the circuit when the fault may have been somewhere else.
Detecting overvoltages could be difficult. Sometimes all that is known is that the pulse transformer sparked over. It is straightforward to conclude that the transformer is defective, since that was the one obvious thing that happened.
The primary check is to be certain the oil is up to standard. Then one should look ahead to larger than normal secondary and primary pulses. This may be difficult, because the malfunction may occur just the moment one takes his eyes off the scope. Also a single high pulse will often not occur during the traditional triggered sweep time of the scope trace. One better way is to watch the
PFN voltage with a reliable voltage divider. A high charging cycle here will be detected more easily. Another possibility that does not require such close watching is to position the normal scope trace in order that it’s just off the scope screen. By turning the intensity very high and using a scope screen that has some persistence (e.g. P2) an overvoltage will fall on the visible a part of the screen and the intensity of the spot and the persistence of the screen will allow viewing after the event.
A rare problem, but one worth including, is for the case of a bifilar transformer carrying heater current, that sparks between the 2 legs of the bifilar. There is normally not enough current within the pulse circuits to break the transformer windings. However the high-voltage spark is followed by a heavy current arc fed by the heater supply. If not properly fused or circuitbreaker protected, this heavy current arc can burn the transformer windings through, resulting in an open winding. If pulsing is continued, this break within the winding will spark over continuously with the pulses, rapidly carbonizing the oil and causing further breakdowns.